The property tax system in New York City is complicated and confusing, and it’s important that owners understand the fundamentals of how their NYC property taxes are determined. This in-depth guide will help property owners understand the process that determines their property values, taxes owed, and tax exemptions and abatements. In addition, we’ll dive into the factors that drive the growth of real estate values and the impact these values have on their taxes.
Understanding the NYC property taxes system is critical to avoiding unexpected financial strain and maintaining a strong relationship with city authorities. It’s also crucial to keeping abreast of key payment deadlines, as failure to make timely payments may result in significant penalties and other consequences.
A significant driver of NYC property taxes system is its large and growing real estate value, which has more than tripled from about $382 billion in fiscal year 2000 to $1.47 trillion in fiscal year 2017. This growth has been driven by a combination of market forces, including increasing demand for housing in the city and region, increased interest in commercial and retail space, and growing prices for existing real estate.
Property assessments, which are the basis for NYC property taxes, are calculated as a fraction of market value using complex rules and procedures that vary by property class. The complex mix of assessment rules and property-class specific calculation methods explains why there are so many disparities in the city’s property taxes.
For example, a homestead exemption can reduce a property’s assessed value and thus lower the property’s tax liability. But a homeowner must keep in mind that the City has a broad array of property-related taxes that are not part of the general NYC property tax, such as the NYC and state transfer tax and the NYC “mansion tax,” which is increasingly being paid by homeowners as the median house price approaches the tax’s $1 million threshold.
The City’s property tax rate has been relatively stable since the 1990s, with only one increase in the rate in recent years. Nonetheless, the growth of the city’s real estate value has fueled dramatic increases in the NYC property tax bills of most property owners, especially those in higher-valued properties.
The wide variation in effective property-tax rates is largely a result of policy decisions by city and state elected officials that shield owners of small residential properties from rapid increases in their taxes, while burdening owners of larger commercial and rental buildings. This substantial disparity makes NYC a less attractive location for businesses and households, while limiting opportunities for those who are not wealthy enough to live in the most desirable parts of town. The City is making steps to address the disparity, including implementing new property tax relief measures. These changes should help curb the growth of NYC property taxes in future years. However, even with the new measures, the city will continue to rely on property-tax revenue to fund its essential services and programs.
If you own real property (a house, apartment or a co-op) in New York City, you have to pay NYC property taxes. Property tax bills are based on the value of the property, which is assessed every year — the process is called assessment. The City determines this market value through statistical analysis of recent sales of similar properties in your neighborhood, taking into account factors such as location, size and age. The Department of Finance then divides the total market value by its assessment class shares and multiplies that number by the City's tax rate to determine a property's tax liability for the fiscal year.
The City's tax rates are set annually by the Council based partially on State law requirements and partly on the need to raise sufficient revenue for the City's programs. Understanding the intricacies of NYC property taxes is crucial for property owners to budget effectively. The City also collects various other taxes, fees, and surcharges on real property, such as the NYC transfer tax and the infamous “mansion” tax that is ensnaring more and more homeowners in Manhattan as they pass the $1 million threshold.
These taxes make up more than a third of the City's total property tax revenue, almost twice as much as its second largest source of revenue, local personal income taxes. The increasing dependence on NYC property taxes highlights the importance of keeping property valuations fair and equitable. The large and growing scale of property tax revenues is tied to the city's high and rising levels of real estate values. In the fiscal years 2000 to 2017, real estate values increased by more than three times, from $382 billion to over $1.4 trillion.
Some property owners pay lower property taxes than others of the same type, and these differences have two causes: (1) the different methods used to evaluate properties for tax purposes and (2) the city's wide array of tax exemption programs with specific eligibility criteria and set benefit levels. This disparity in NYC property taxes raises questions about the fairness of the tax system. A number of these programs have very high effective tax rate (“ETR”) differentials, including individual residential owner-occupied tax exemptions based on income, residency, and disability; and housing development, economic development, and 421a commercial building construction and renovation abatements with defined eligibility criteria. The City should restructure these programs so that they include only property owners who truly need the benefits and can bear the burden of paying for the public costs associated with these exemptions.
The City's overall property tax rate has been relatively stable since the 1990s, and there have only been three changes in the tax rate since then. However, even when the rate has been stable, tax bills have continued to increase because of the growth in market value. The consistent rise in market value significantly impacts NYC property taxes, underscoring the need for continuous reassessment of properties.
In many cases, property owners are able to reduce their assessment by filing an application for property tax relief with the NYC Tax Commission before March 1 of each year. You can find information about the process here. You should always consult an attorney before trying to appeal your property taxes. However, if you feel that the market value of your property is overstated, you can file an assessment challenge with the Department of Finance between January 15 and March 1. You may also contact us to discuss whether you might qualify for a tax abatement.
Property taxes are an integral part of the cost of owning a home or business, and understanding how NYC assesses value can significantly impact your NYC property tax liability. We’ll explore the factors that influence your property tax, including market and class, as well as the City’s complex system of evaluation and calculating property values.
New York City property taxes are determined primarily by the property’s market and class, as well as its use and other factors. The City determines a property’s market value through a process that considers recent sales data, property characteristics, and neighborhood trends. It is important to note that the assessed value derived from this process directly affects the amount of NYC property taxes owed by a homeowner. A property’s actual market value is then compared to similar properties in the same neighborhood to establish its assessed value, which is then multiplied by the applicable tax rate to determine a property’s tax liability.
Properties in the City are divided into four property classes. Class 1 includes one- to three-family homes, and class 2 includes residential buildings with more than three units (including co-ops and condominiums). Class 3 includes utility company equipment, and class 4 covers all other real property. The differentiation in classes plays a crucial role in calculating NYC property taxes.
The City sets a tax rate for each property class based on local needs and state law requirements. These rates are vital components in the final calculation of NYC property taxes. The City’s tax rates are set annually to reflect current market conditions and to help ensure a fair and equitable distribution of the tax burden among all property owners.
A property’s assessed and taxable value is determined by the Department of Finance. Using an extensive methodology, the City evaluates each property in its jurisdiction to compare with comparable properties in terms of size, location, and features. This careful evaluation process ensures the accuracy of NYC property taxes. In addition to comparing market prices and class, the City also considers the amount of renovations or improvements that have been completed on a property.
Once the City determines a property’s value, it will publish its tentative assessments on January 15, and then have up to May 24 to review each assessment and make any changes. A property owner may file an appeal with the City to have a property’s assessment decreased or increased.
Prioritizing property tax payments is a vital step in maintaining your property’s value and ensuring access to City services. However, not everyone has the time or resources to understand their tax obligation. We can provide a simplified guide to NYC property taxes to help you make informed decisions about paying your property tax bill. We can also walk you through the delicate process of filing a property tax appeal, providing insight into what steps to take and what your potential financial benefits could be.
Avenue Law Firm
360 Madison Ave, 9th Floor, New York, NY 10017
(212) 729-4090